Police
Reforms: India
Police
Reforms: Too Important to Neglect, Too Urgent to Delay
India's
police are governed by archaic and colonial police laws harking
back to 1861. Under the Indian Constitution, policing is a state
power, which means that state governments have the responsibility
to provide their communities with a police service (the national
government has the responsibility for policing in union territories).
Most state governments have a police law that adopts or reflects
the basic ideas of the 1861 legislation.
There
has been almost 30 years of debate on policing and reform in
India, with commission after commission submitting reports and
recommendations to governments. Each report has gone unimplemented.
At the end of 2006, there was a shift in the reform process,
with a Supreme Court decision that required Indian governments
to ensure police accountability and the release of a draft Model
Police Act by a national Police Act Drafting Committee.
The
Supreme Court directives
In
1996, two former Director Generals of Police asked the Supreme
Court to direct central and state governments to address the
most glaring gaps and bad practice in the functioning of the
police.
On
22 September 2006, the Supreme Court of India delivered a historic
judgment in Prakash Singh vs. Union of India, instructing
central and state governments to comply with a set of seven
directives that laid down practical mechanisms to kick-start
police reform. The Court's directives sought to achieve functional
autonomy for the police (through security of tenure, streamlined
appointment and transfer processes, and the creation of a "buffer
body" between the police and the government) and enhanced police
accountability (both for organisational performance and individual
misconduct.)
The
Supreme Court required all governments, at centre and state
levels, to comply with the seven directives by 31 December 2006
and to file affidavits of compliance by the 3rd of January 2007.
State government responses varied tremendously, ranging from
complying in time with the directives through executive orders,
to expressing strong objections to the directives and asking
the Court to conduct a review.
For
more information on the directives and on compliance with the
directives, click here.
Police
Act Drafting Committee
In
October 2005, the central government set up a Police Act Drafting
Committee (PADC) - commonly know as the Soli Sorabjee Committee
- and asked it to draft a new model bill to guide state government's
adoption of new police laws. The PADC was required to take into
account the changing roles, responsibilities and challenges
of policing. The PADC submitted its Model Police Act to the
Home Ministry on 30 October 2006.
For
more information on the PADC, click here.
Click here
to access a copy of the Model Police Act.
Police
organisation and structure
Click
here
to read more about police organisation and structure in India.
Police
reform initiatives
Click
here
to find out about police reform initiatives in India. Click
here
to download a copy of CHRI's report Police reform debates
in India.
Aim
The
aim of CHRI's India police programme is to develop and disseminate
police reform and accountability expertise, build civil society
capacity to advocate for police reform and advise on police
accountability, catalyse demand for police reform, particularly
around the Supreme Court directives and the Model Police Act
and to monitor government compliance with the Supreme Court
directives.
Activities
In
2006, CHRI facilitated a series of civil society consultation
workshops across India, bringing the police reform debate to
the community. Also in 2006, the programme sat on the government
Police Act Drafting Committee, providing a critical human rights
and civil society voice as a model law was drafted for India.
CHRI also intervened in the Supreme Court case Prakash Singh.
CHRI
continues to monitor compliance with the Supreme Court directives
and to advocate for police accountability and reform around
the Model Police Act and the directives.
A
list of past conferences and workshops is set out below. Click
on the relevant link for more information or background material.
A
people’s campaign for better policing – India national
workshop (Delhi, April 2007)
People's
Participation in Police Reform: A Consultation for the North
East of India (Guwahati, February 2007)
Roundtable
on policing and public order in India (Delhi, June 2006)
Media
on police reform (Delhi, March 2005)
Roundtable
conference on police reforms (Delhi, October 2002)
Madhya
Pradesh Police Bill workshop (Bhopal, May 2002)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill workshop (Jabalpur, January 2002)
Prevention of Terrorism Ordinance – Eminent group discussion
(Delhi, November 2001)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill – Public meeting (Itarsi, October
2001)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill – Public meeting (Vidhisha,
October 2001)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill – Public meeting (Raisen, October
2001)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill – Media workshop (Bhopal, September
2001)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill – Workshop (Bhopal, August
2001)
Madhya Pradesh Police Bill – Workshop (Indore, July 2001)
Police reform workshop (Gwalior, April 2001)
Police reform workshop (Shimla, March 2001)
Police reform workshop (Hyderabad, August 2000)
Police reform for police officers (Delhi, July 2000)
Police reform workshop (Delhi, May 2000)
Police reform for police officers (Delhi, February 2000)
Police reform workshop (Bhopal, December 1999)
Police reform – Southern regional workshop (Hyderabad,
August 1999)
Police reform workshop (Delhi, May 1999)
Police reform workshop (Delhi, August 1998)
Publications
CHRI’s
publications on policing in India are listed here.
Electronic copies are available for download, or request a hardcopy
of a particular publication by clicking here.
Current
events
The
next Supreme Court hearing in Prakash Singh is currently
set down for 31 August 2007.
Media
statements
The
people take on police reform: Peoples’ campaign for better
policing begins with national roundtable – Friday
27 April 2007.
Laws
and standards
National
laws are available here.
Contact
For
more information on CHRI’s work in India, contact Navaz Kotwal.